MAFIA: The Treason of Isengard- Day 5 Legolas Killed

[mr. dude]

@Mr.dude, dunno, we just didn't like you , I didn't see you were a tracker or anything, I dunno really

I like that better than having bad timing, alright

[The Newbie]

We were really struggling at more than one point.

The only time I can see Mafia struggling was the second to last day. If we'd lynched LonelyKnight when I said to we'd have had an extra day to find you...ah well. It's in the past now.

I just think the mass amount special characters spoilt the game a bit. Also having an 'inactive' player take part in the game (without confirming?) seems wrong. Especially with such a game changing winning condition. He was our only true link to finding you out.

In fact is ad??? even a member anymore? I can't find him in the members directory.

[ukrocky]

He is, just not been online since Feb 20th.

[Chris Guard of Mardat]

Poor mr. dude, the Mafia seemed to have picked on you, but at least it didn't seem like everyone though you were a Mafia member (this was sort of my fault as I decided to play so everyone was suspicious of me, making it less likely for the Mafia to kill me in the night so I could undergo investigation) I'll set Treebeard on you!

{aD}??? being inactive was definitely not helpful for the Mafia, although maybe he was doing this so he didn't get lynched, or was voteless until Saruman died.

@ukrocky: did I steal the palantir from you, and if so, did it stop you being a role-cop?

[LonelyKnight]

His username is {aD}??? so he's under the # list in the members

I think we targetted mr dude the first time because we decided to whack a silent one on that night.
The second time I really wanted to have a go at you again, I don't like unfinished business.

[The Newbie]

stealing items does nothing to people's abilities.

{ad???} not being active was ultimately helpful to the mafia, it meant they could lynch him and gain some trustworthiness. It was not helpful to us because we couldn't find out the godfather.

[ukrocky]

Yeah it stopped me being a rolecop and yeah it was my palantir

[mr. dude]

Makes sense.
Now why would CG protect me?

[ukrocky]

Makes sense.
Now why would CG protect me?

I think he protected a random person (which was silly IMO) and it got him killed off early on totally randomly. It helped us tbh.

[Chris Guard of Mardat]

So could {aD}??? have confirmed that he was going to participate in the game, when were the character profiles sent out? (I got mine late, which is why I'm asking, and why I didn't speak for a while)

Who did everyone believe to be Mafia?

@Matt-Shadowlord: will you running another game soon? I really enjoyed this game, despite the loss, and I think everyone else did too. Thank-you for taking the time to run a great game